How Much to Spend on an Engagement Ring without Going Broke

Author: | Date:

Are you looking to BTO soon and you’re worried about how much to spend on your engagement ring? There are important questions that many avoid at this point: what if your engagement doesn’t work out last minute? What if either of you has cold feet at that point in time? You may worry about her breaking your heart (or bank account) last minute… and all that thousands of dollars spent on that engagement ring goes to… waste.

Engagement Ring Singapore 03

I’ll argue that the majority of personal finance issues can be boiled down to an ability to communicate openly, set boundaries between friendships, relationships and money. If you think about it, how many people you know go bankrupt or land themselves in a bad financial situation because of their ability say no to people around them? Whether it be an important issue such as a guarantor loan to taking up a mortgage that they can’t afford? Thinking about how much to spend on your engagement ring is no different.

How Much People Spend on an Engagement Ring

There’s a lot of personal finance out there advising on the budget of your engagement ring. Here’s the all too common advice: you should spend 3 months of your income on an engagement ring. Now, let’s take a look at some statistics. There’s a study stating that the majority of males in Singapore are willing to spend around $5,000 to $7,900 on their engagement ring. Singaporean females, on the other hand, are only expecting their partner to spend between $2,000 to $4,900.

Engagement Ring SIngapore 01

That’s surprising. You’ll think that the ladies are the ones that would be less conservative in expectations (not including the obvious gold diggers of course.)

Here’s my advice: the amount to spend on an engagement ring should be tied to your ability to afford it (your income) and what your partner desires.

Ultimately, it’s up to you and your partner’s decision. If you want to spend $15,000 on a ring, kudos to you. If you want to spend lower and use that extra cash on an awesome honeymoon trip. That’s up to you as well. I know of a guy that spent $1,000 on his ring, and he’s still happily married today.

Secondly, by asking your fiancée to send you ideas of what she likes, you’re also making sure she’s going be excited about the gift she is going to wear for the rest of her life. Thus, you can consider getting her to WhatsApp, Email you ideas and get something that she really likes.

Engagement Ring SIngapore 05
Some ideas.

So how can you openly discuss the cost of the ring and the type of ring you want to get with your fiancée?

Firstly, there are cultural narratives suggesting that discussing the type/cost of engagement ring your partner wants is embarrassing and you should keep it as a complete surprise. That’s especially true for us Singaporean males. You’re brought up in a culture to be ‘face savvy.’ That’s limiting. Your partner is going to appreciate the open communication and commitment to help the relationship work out financially the long run.

Okay, if you’re unable to come up with your own version of open communication, let me help you with that with our exact word for word scripts.

Exact Word for Word Scripts for Your Engagement Rings:

Hey Jane, I really love you and I’m excited to spend the rest of our lives together. I know we’ve getting married, flats and BTO already, but there’s actually something I feel it’ll be good for both of us to discuss. I want to talk about the ring. It’s something I’ve been thinking about and I’m guessing you may be thinking about that as well.’

‘Do you have any kind of ring in mind? I’d love to hear what you think.’

‘I really appreciate that we can be open about this. I’d like to put in serious thought about this. It’s great to talk about this and I’m excited for the next step.’

Okay, these scripts are assuming she’s looking for a ring that you can afford with your income level. However, what if she’s looking for an engagement ring that you can’t afford? (Read: you need to be painfully honest with yourself here.)

Exact Line For Line Scripts if She Wants a Ring You Can’t Afford

‘Hey I appreciate openly discussing what you’re looking for the last night. From the last time both of us discussed, it seemed like the ring you want was XYZ. Is that correct?’
(This clarifies any misunderstandings you may have)

‘Jane, I’d love to get the ring of your dreams… however, I also want to be thoughtful about our finances as we build our lives together.’
(This reiterates how you’re keeping both parties’ (the relationship) as your concern)

‘Based on my finances, I can’t do the one you want right now. However, I appreciate you telling me that want you’re looking and I’ll do my best in finding the most perfect right to signify our relationship.
(You’ll need to be directly honest here and be also considerate of what she wants)

‘Thanks, that was really great. I appreciate having this discussion. I appreciate you for listening to my concerns. It feels great to know that we can have an open discussion like this’.

This may be perceived by many as totally unromantic or embarrassing in a Singaporean Asian culture. However, I’ll debate that it’s open communicating that helps in any relationship. You’re also making a financial decision that’ll help the relationship down the line.

The Engagement Ring Industry

In the engagement ring industry, it’s engineered to encourage you to spend more. This includes creating rating metrics like the 4 Cs, cut, colour, clarity and carat. There are catch lines such as ‘a diamond is forever’ splashed across advertising campaigns.

Engagement Ring Singapore 04

There’s an interesting survey that suggests that when it comes to the diamond, mostly only size and bling matters. Yes, you may think the ‘4Cs’ matter, however, at the end of the day, it’s the size that people go gaga about because size is easily comparable.

‘You are judged by the size of the diamond. The bigger then it is assumed you have money. Common sense goes out of the window.’

– Survey Respondent

If you didn’t get that. Here’s a bottom line: the 2 crucial elements of an engagement that really matter: size and bling. You should factor your purchasing decision based on these two metrics.

How to Negotiate the Price of Your Engagement Ring

Since the engagement ring industry is designed to get you to spend more, you’ll need to be able to negotiate the price of the engagement ring. The best way to do it is to do the majority of your research before actually stepping into any jewellery stores. One of the simplest ways to negotiate is to cite a price that the jewellery competitor is offering and request for the price to be reduced. You’ll be surprised that this simple negotiation strategy can get you a price reduction in many instances.

You’ll need to negotiate the price of your ring because it’s researched that the resale value of engagement rings are generally at a low rate of 15% of the original price. So, if you’re spending $1,000 on a ring, expect it to be $150 the moment you resell it. In other words, you can forget about reselling your ring if your engagement goes awry.

How to Spend Whatever You Want on an Engagement Ring:

So, if you’d like to spend however much you desire on an engagement ring, you’ll need to figure out how to make more money right? You’ll need to find out ways on how to save more money, earn more money and then grow your money. If you don’t know by now (and you should!), here at Dr Wealth, we have over 600 published articles on how you can 1.) Save money, 2.) Earn more money, and 3.) Grow your money by investing.

To get you started, you can check out our articles on:

Lastly, I’d like to end off by reasserting that a lot of financial problems arise because of an inability to openly communicate: from minor financial decisions such as lending money to friends that you don’t have to overspending on an engagement ring.

This is why you need fundamental personal finance skillsets such as negotiation: making it a win-win and an ability to say no to yourself and others when it comes to important financial decisions.

Image Credits: FayImage.Com

5 thoughts on “How Much to Spend on an Engagement Ring without Going Broke”

  1. WOW!

    Just 15% of the original purchase price? De Beers has certainly done a good job of marketing Carbon.

    Maybe a plan would be to find a secondhand ring and have a new ring custom made with the stone set in it.

    Your sweetheart need never know,

    “I had this ring custom made just for you!”

  2. My ring was $500. Didn’t want a diamond and didn’t see the need to buy an expensive ring. Would rather he fund my retirement 😉

Leave a Comment