The heydays of earning big bucks through real estate are over, and property isn’t the best asset class to invest in anymore, opines an industry expert.
Words by Seng Bingyang
Recently, I had the pleasure of catching up with one of my friends who is an institutional investor specialising in real estate investments. I took the opportunity to ask him a few questions regarding real estate that puzzled me.
You see, I meet and speak with many young working professionals in my line of work.
Here's our mistakes. Don't do the same.
We asked 14 Singapore finance bloggers to share what they would do if they could go back in time and invest their first $20,000. They can no longer rewind time, but you can learn from their experience and hopefully start with a better footing.
One of the key observations I made in my discussions with them is this: when asked what strategy they intend to use to achieve their financial goals, with little hesitation, many of them answer that they want to do so through property investments.
Sometimes, it seems as though that’s the only thing people know to do.
Because I strongly believe it is important for DrWealth readers and people who are interested in financial planning to have a better understanding of property as an asset class in Singapore, I want to share the gist of my “interview” with him here.
Note: As my friend prefers to remain anonymous (to avoid any possible conflict of interest with his work), let me simply introduce him as Mr Joe Black.
So ladies and gentlemen, meet Joe Black.
Bingyang: Why do you think so many young professionals talk about investing in property to achieve their financial goals? It puzzles me because they are banking on capital appreciation that I believe is not guaranteed anymore.
Joe Black: People still believe that buying property is the way to become rich. This is because in the last 20 years, property has grown by 5 to 6% on average.
Those who have bought and leveraged on property in the last 20 years have grown very rich.
BY: Right. Sounds like many people of the earlier generation used property investments to great effect. Do you think this will continue to be the case for today’s generation?
JB: Because continuous growth in the last 20 years has made property prices in Singapore inexplicably high, the potential to grow further is now limited.
Do you think that any of us can afford anything in the property market (bar HDBs) if prices continue to grow at 5%? Even if we can afford HDBs, I wouldn’t dare say that they are cheap!
Why, you may ask.
This is because land in Singapore is charged to HDB at market rates, which is exorbitant, and this cost is passed on to the end users. There is only so much you can subsidise public housing if the cost of input (including land) is already this high.
[Photo Credit: HDB]
BY: What about property as a hedge to inflation?
JB: Sure. You may point out that property is a hedge to inflation because it is generally accepted that rental income tends to grow with inflation.
However, rental yields are coming down quite sharply today. I have many friends who are renting and lowballing their landlords.
After paying your agents and stamp duties, plus the occasional repair and cleaning, what you get back is around 1 to 2%. For all the effort that goes into maintaining your property for a 1-2% yield, there are better instruments out there that you can make use of that pay more with half the hassle.
BY: Let’s talk about the cooling measures that have been introduced. How have they affected the property market?
JB: Cooling measures by our government have helped by slowing the market down. This is good because if prices continue to grow due to the currently insane speculation, the bubble has to burst one day. When people who buy investment properties realise that they are unable to rent them out, it will indirectly deflate property prices.
Just look around Singapore right now, there are so many condos that are bought up. These properties are owned, but nobody is living in them.
Unless our population suddenly increases, the supply outweighs demand and one day, the depreciating rental rates will cause property prices to go down.
Never before in history has so much of our people’s wealth been tied up in property. When the market goes down, mortgage will go up. So some people will lose their homes, and along with it, all their wealth and hard-earned savings.
With that being said, the government will always need to ensure that housing prices, especially for public housing, don’t go crazy because it will hurt their popularity. On that front, they are doing some things to help – for example, there has been talk of raising the income cap for public housing.
Construction is also one of the big drivers of our economy, so we must not let the property market crash. If and when it happens, Singapore will fall into political mayhem.
BY: If property isn’t the best asset to invest in anymore, are there any alternatives?
JB: Absolutely! Look, I’m not saying that property should no longer be looked at anymore. What I’m trying to bring to light is that it is dangerous if we were to place the same expectations for growth on our property investments going forward.
Too many people want to jump on the property bandwagon because of cognitive bias (a pattern of deviation in judgment, whereby inferences about other people and situations may be drawn in an illogical fashion) without doing their homework.
My personal take is that most assets seem over-valued right now. Housing and stock valuations are at all-time highs even though economies are not doing well. The effect of easy money (Quantitative Easing for those in the know) is really starting to show.
So the key is to protect yourself from losing money and not blindly following the herd and speculating.
There will still be corrections in the markets which investors can take advantage of. But if one doesn’t have time to track the market carefully, plus the fact that it is always incredibly hard to time the market, perhaps regular savings plans and investment plans are still the way to go for many individuals.
BY: Let me ask a question on behalf of our readers, many of whom may not have the capital right now to invest in a property, but would still like to gain exposure to the property market. What’s your opinion on Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs)?
JB: Often the fund manager’s objective is not aligned to the shareholders’ objectives. As they are paid on Assets under Management (AUM), they may take on unnecessary risks to try to get a higher rate of return. When the party is over, however, shareholders will feel the crash of the market.
Furthermore, each time they buy or sell, they charge a fee.
However, REITs are still one of the only avenues for retail consumers to get exposure to commercial properties. My advice is, just be aware of both the pros and cons before you put any money into investing.
This article originally appeared on Seng Bingyang’s blog and has been republished here with permission.